Newsletter October 7, 2026

Using the Wick Selector: A guide for real bench testing.

Don't just guess your wick size. We walk through how to use the Wick Selector tool and what it actually tells you when planning a new batch.

5 min readWicks, Tools, Troubleshooting, Testing

A close view of a messy candle workbench with several small, unlit candles in jars and pillar molds. Various thin braided cords with small metal tabs are laid out next to the containers and wax cups, ready for testing.

When guessing is not an option

In my experience, the most common mistake a new maker can make is “eyeballing” their wick choice. It feels like it should be simple—you pick a jar and you pick a wick that looks right. However, candle making relies on physics and chemistry. If your wick is too small, you get tunneling; if it’s too large, the flame becomes unstable or creates an excessive amount of soot. Neither result makes for a good product, and both can lead to safety concerns.

I approach this with the same discipline I learned in the military: don’t guess when there is data available to inform your decision. You want to start from a position of certainty so that you aren’t wasting wax or time on batches that won’t perform correctly. The goal isn’t just to make a candle that burns; it’s to make one that performs consistently every time. Using a tool like the wick selector gives you a starting point from a supplier’s published chart so you can focus your bench testing on refining, rather than guessing from scratch.

How the Wick Selector actually works (and what it uses)

A hand using a caliper tool to measure the inside diameter of an empty candle container or pillar mold on a workbench. The measurement is written down in a notebook.
Always measure your containers and pillars before you start. Consistency here saves hours of frustration later.

The wick selector is designed to take the guesswork out of the initial selection process by using the tables in the CandleScience Wick Guide. When you input your specific details—such as your wax type, whether it’s a pillar or jar candle, and the inner diameter of your container—the tool cross-references those specs against known performance data.

It doesn’t just give you one answer; it gives you a range. For instance, if two different wick series are listed as options for your wax, they are alternatives. You should pick one brand or style and stick with it to maintain consistency in your production. The tool also provides the “neighboring” sizes on the chart. These aren’t just extra options; they are there because you need a range of data points to test against. By providing these three specific wicks (the suggested size, one size down, and one size up), the tool gives you a clear roadmap for your initial burn tests so you can see how each size behaves in your specific setup.

A simple walkthrough: getting your first batch plan

When you are ready to start a new project, I recommend following a strict process to ensure consistency. First, measure your container’s internal diameter exactly; don’t guess based on what the manufacturer says it is, as every jar can vary slightly. Once you have that measurement and know which wax you intend to use, enter those details into the wick selector.

For a standard jar candle, the tool will suggest a specific wick based on your container’s width. For pillar or votive candles, it provides recommendations for freestanding designs. In both cases, you should plan to test three different wicks: the one suggested by the tool and the two sizes immediately adjacent to it on the chart. This “rule of three” ensures that if the primary suggestion is slightly too small or too large due to your specific fragrance load or container material, you have a backup ready for testing. Documenting these results in a burn log from the very first batch will help you track what works and why before you ever try to sell a single candle.

The rules of the bench test: what the calculator won’t tell you

Three finished candles—one small, one medium, and one large—are set up on a clean surface in preparation for burn testing.
Remember to test three sizes: the suggested size, plus one smaller wick, and plus one larger wick. This gives you a full picture.

It is important to remember that while the wick selector provides an excellent starting point, it cannot account for every variable on your workbench. Specifically, high fragrance loads or heavy amounts of dye can change how a wick performs since the supplier’s chart was tested without dye and with a fixed fragrance load. If you are using a high load of fragrance oil, you may find that you need to move toward the larger size in your test group.

When you begin your burn tests, do not just light them once and walk away. You should burn each of your three test wicks for at least four hours. This allows you to see how the melt pool develops over time and ensures the candle burns correctly all the way down. Candles often run hotter as the wax level drops, so a wick that works perfectly at the top might struggle near the bottom. Use these tests to look for specific signs: a small flame with tunneling indicates a wick is too small; a tall, flickering flame or an overheating container suggests it is too large. For more on how to read these signs, see our candle wicks guide.

Special situations to consider before pouring

There are several specific scenarios where you need to be extra cautious and follow a stricter testing protocol. First, pillar and votive candles have no container to hold the wax in place; if your wick is too large, it can melt through the sides of the candle and leak out. If your pillar size falls between two sizes on a chart, always start with the smaller one to ensure safety. You should review our pillar and votive guide before attempting these types of pours.

For larger containers—generally those 3.8 inches in diameter or wider—you may need to consider multi-wicking. This is a different technical challenge that requires its own set of tests. Additionally, if you are working with beeswax, be aware that it is notoriously difficult to wick correctly and does not follow the same standard charts as soy or paraffin blends; in these cases, we recommend starting with ECO wicks for better stability. Always consult your wax supplier’s data sheet for their specific recommendations before moving into large-scale production. If you find yourself struggling with a specific issue during testing, our troubleshooter can help you identify the root cause.

Read more on the site: Wick Selector


Get the next issue

Questions or corrections? Send a note. Or read more issues.